Nails

Killer Claws: 3 Free Wiki

Also known as “Big 3 Free,” 3 Free refers to nail polish devoid of the chemicals formaldehyde, toluene, and dibutyl phthalate (DBP). The demand for 3 Free nail polish began around the year 2004 and has increasingly become a public health debate [2], resulting in many manufacturers voluntarily going 3 Free.

1.    Toxins
  1.1    Formaldehyde
  1.2    Toluene
  1.3    Dibutyl phthalate (DBP)
2.    Loopholes, Mislabeling and Controversy
3.    Future Legality
4.    3 Free Brands

Toxins

Formaldehyde

According to the US National Toxicology Program, formaldehyde is a carcinogen. It is also widely used as a preservative and is a primary ingredient in embalming fluid. While formaldehyde in its base form is found only in nail hardeners, nail polishes use a resin derivative called tosylamide, which helps polish to harden and adhere [8 6 5]. Formaldehyde resin is known to cause acute upper respiratory irritation and contact dermatitis [8 6 2].

Toluene

Toluene is an industrial solvent found in crude oil. It is used to keep nail polish liquefied and smooth [8 6 5]. Toluene is a known neurotoxin that causes dizziness, decreased cognitive function, euphoria, sleepiness and, in some cases, death, according to the US National Pollutant Inventory. In pregnant women, toluene is capable of crossing the placenta and causing the fetus to have developmental abnormalities [2]. In cases of abuse such as huffing, toluene can also cause brain damage and dementia [8].

Dibutyl pthalalte (DBP)

Dibutyl phthalate (DBP) is a plasticizer used to make nail polish more flexible and thereby prevent chipping [8 6 2]. It is commonly used to make polymers such as PVC, adhesives and inks [5]. Arguably the most dangerous of the Big 3, DBP was banned in the European Union in 2004 under Directive 76/768/EEC, and was added to California Proposition 65 for suspected causation of physiological abnormalities [6].

Loopholes, Mislabeling and Controversy

While consumer calls to action have resulted in voluntary cessation in use of the Big 3 [3], all are permitted in use of cosmetics by the FDA.

Several instances of 3 Free mislabeling have been noted [2 9 1 7]. In April 2012, the California EPA’s Department of Toxic Substances Control conducted a study in which 25 polishes labeled as 3 Free were chosen at random and tested for the Big 3. They found that ten of a dozen products claiming to be free of toluene actually contained it; four brands with dangerously high levels. Five of the seven products claiming to be entirely 3 Free included high levels of one or more of the chemicals [1].

The safety of formaldehyde resin, or tosylamide, has yet to be determined, and industry activists claim that some manufacturers are able to use the 3 Free designation just because their polishes don’t contain pure formaldehyde [9 2].

Future Legality

The Cosmetics Safety Enhancement Act of 2012 was introduced to the House Committee on Energy and Commerce by Representative Frank Pallone (D-NJ) on March 26 2013. If passed, the bill would grant the FDA power to demand a recall of toxic cosmetics. However, it would not require manufacturers to remove toxins, nor would they fully have to disclose their ingredients.

3 Free Brands [4]

  • Formaldehyde and DBP Free – Carolyn New York, CND (Creative Nail Design) and NYX
  • Big 3 Free – butter London, Calvin Klein, China Glaze (black label), Color Club, Essie, Finger Paints, Hard Candy, Illamasqua, Maybelline Express Finish, Maybelline Salon Expert, Nicole, OPI (green label) and Sally Hansen Salon
  • Big 3 Free, No Formaldehyde Resin – MAC, Milani, N.Y.C. Long Wearing, Nailtini (except Vodka), NARS, Nocti, Orly, PeaceKeeper, Pop Beauty Nail Glam, Rescue Beauty Lounge, SpaRitual and Wet n’ Wild
  • Big 3 Free, No Formaldehyde Resin, No Camphor – Chanel, Dashing Diva, Dior, Estee Lauder, Givenchy, Lancome, Lippmann, L’oreal, No-Miss, Nubar, NYC In A New York Color Minute, Revlon, Rimmel London 60 Seconds, Sally Hansen Insta-Dri, Sante, Shades by Barielle, Shu Uemura, Sinful Colors and Zoya
  • Water based, Big 3 Free, No Formaldehyde Resin, No Camphor, No Ethyl Acetate – Acquarella, Honeybee Gardens, Sula and Suncoat
  1.  “Calif. Report Reveals “non-toxic” Nail Polishes Could Cause Birth Defects.” CBSNews. CBS Interactive, 10 Apr. 2012. Web. 03 Mar. 2013. <http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504763_162-57411794-10391704/calif-report-reveals-non-toxic-nail-polishes-could-cause-birth-defects/>.
  2. “Concerned Advocates, Companies Respond to Calif. “toxic” Nail Polish Report.” CBSNews. CBS Interactive, 11 Apr. 2012. Web. 03 Mar. 2013. <Concerned>.
  3. Craft, Kyle. “Non Toxic Revolution.” Keep A Breast Foundation. N.p., 26 Mar. 2012. Web. 03 Mar. 2013. <Craft>.
  4. Mismas, Michelle. “The Big 3.” All Lacquered Up. AllLacqueredUp.com, 11 May 2007. Web. 05 Mar. 2013. <http://www.alllacqueredup.com/2007/05/big-3-chemicals-that-is.html>.
  5. Mismas, Michelle. “Celebrate Earth Day — Check Your Ingredients.” All Lacquered Up. N.p., 22 Apr. 2009. Web. 04 Mar. 2013. <http://www.alllacqueredup.com/2009/04/celebrate-earth-day-check-your.html>.
  6. “PassionForPolish: What Is Big 3 Free?” PassionForPolish: What Is Big 3 Free? N.p., n.d. Web. 03 Mar. 2013. <PassionForPolish>.
  7. Sole-Smith, Virginia. “Toxins Found in “Toxin-Free” Nail Polish: Another Reason Beauty Regulation Needs a Makeover.” Slate.com | The XX Factor. Slate.com, 13 Apr. 2012. Web. 01 Mar. 2013. <Sole-Smith>.
  8. “The Science of “3 Free” Nail Polish.” Persephone Magazine. Persephone Magazine, 8 Mar. 2011. Web. 03 Mar. 2013. <The Science>.
  9. Stanell, Victoria. “What Really Makes a Nail Polish Green?” Beautylish. Beautylish.com, 4 Apr. 2012. Web. 01 Mar. 2013. <Stanell>.

Previous post

Tutorial: For Mani(c) Monday. No-polish, natural nails.

Next post

Tutorial: Zig Zag aka Chevron Manicure

Comments

  • 10 Quick and Easy Nail Tips – argypirate

    […] it’s gross, and you should definitely make sure your polish is 3 Free before you go wagging your tongue, but some fresh smudges can be fixed by the slippery slickness of […]

  • pickyfoodlover

    I don’t paint my nails that often but I’m relieved to see that some of the brands I use are 3 Free! I love OPI and New York Color Minute and Sally Hansen. I enjoy to niche you chose to follow. It’s very off-beat (at least I haven’t seen much on the subject. But then again, I haven’t searched for it either). Very well researched. I can tell you have a real passion for this.

  • bouchard308

    Really well done! Way to go finding an uncovered niche of a well-researched topic. This is exactly what I was hoping for because it allows you to provides lots of links to other wiki entries. It’s also an important public health topic to increase exposure to the public.

    • argypirate

      Thanks professor Bouchard. I thought this would be more interesting than a company biography. I tried to keep it as factually basic as possible. There are all manner of unsubstantiated health claims abuzz on the interweb. I had a great time linking to external resources, too. Should we be trying to do that in our blog entries as well? What about promoting other sites as general resources?

Leave a Reply